Creamy Seafood Stuffed Shells

These seafood stuffed shells transform any dinner into a luxurious restaurant-quality experience at home. The combination of sweet lobster and delicate crab wrapped in pasta and smothered in a silky sauce creates an unforgettable meal that feels celebratory yet is surprisingly manageable to prepare.

I first created this recipe for my husband's birthday dinner, and it has since become our tradition for celebrating milestones. The look on his face when I bring this bubbling dish to the table is worth every minute spent preparing it.

Ingredients

• Lobster meat: provides sweet tender bites and creates that luxury restaurant feeling at home; use fresh when possible but good quality frozen works well too
• Lump crab meat: offers delicate flavor that complements the lobster without overpowering; look for refrigerated pasteurized crab for best quality to price ratio
• Garlic cloves: create an aromatic base that enhances the seafood; choose firm bulbs with tight skin for the freshest flavor
• All-purpose flour: thickens the sauce to a silky consistency without making it gummy; use a measuring tbsp to avoid over thickening
• Salt and pepper: balance and enhance all the flavors; always taste and adjust as you go
• Mozzarella cheese: provides that stretchy melty texture essential for comfort food; freshly shredded melts much better than prepackaged
• Butter: adds richness and helps sauté the garlic; use unsalted to control the final saltiness
• Cream cheese: creates a creamy stable base for the filling that holds the seafood pieces letting them shine through
• Heavy whipping cream: develops a luxurious sauce that coats each shell perfectly; don’t substitute with lighter options the sauce won’t set properly
• Parmesan Reggiano cheese: contributes deep savory notes that complement seafood wonderfully; invest in real Parmigiano Reggiano for noticeably better flavor

Step-by-Step Instructions

Preheat Oven:

Set your oven to exactly 375°F and thoroughly grease a 9x13 baking dish making sure to get into the corners. Using a glass dish allows you to see when the bottom is bubbling properly.

Prepare the Seafood:

Gently examine both lobster and crab for any bits of shell or cartilage. Chop lobster into half-bite pieces while leaving some crab lumps larger for textural contrast. Pat both meats dry with paper towels to prevent a watery filling.

Make the Filling:

In a large mixing bowl soften cream cheese until easily spreadable then fold in half the Parmesan and half cup mozzarella until well combined. Gently fold in the prepared seafood with a rubber spatula to maintain those beautiful chunks. Season with salt and pepper starting conservatively as the cheeses already contain salt.

Cook the Sauce:

In a medium saucepan melt butter over medium heat until it stops foaming but before it browns. Add minced garlic and cook for exactly 30 seconds until fragrant but not brown which would create bitterness. Sprinkle flour evenly across the butter and whisk continuously for 60 seconds to cook out the raw flour taste. While whisking constantly slowly pour in the heavy cream and bring to a gentle simmer until the sauce thickens enough to coat the back of a spoon. Stir in remaining Parmesan until completely melted and smooth.

Stuff the Shells:

Hold each cooked pasta shell in your palm and spoon approximately 1.5 tablespoons of filling into each cavity pressing gently to fill completely but not split the pasta. Arrange filled shells open side up in your prepared baking dish placing them close enough to support each other but not overcrowded.

Assemble the Dish:

Pour the warm cream sauce evenly over the arranged shells ensuring each receives coverage. Sprinkle remaining mozzarella in an even layer across the top focusing slightly more on the center where it tends to melt faster.

Bake and Serve:

Cover the dish tightly with aluminum foil being careful not to let it touch the cheese. Bake for exactly 20 minutes then remove foil and continue baking for 10 more minutes until edges are bubbling vigorously and cheese develops golden brown spots. Let rest for 5 minutes before serving to allow sauce to set.

Pin it

You Must Know

This recipe reminds me of summers spent in coastal Maine where my grandmother would splurge on fresh lobster for special family gatherings. She taught me that seafood should be treated simply with respect for its delicate flavor. The cream cheese in this recipe was her secret to keeping the seafood moist during baking.

Perfect Pasta Shells

Cooking the pasta shells properly is crucial for this dish. Boil them for exactly 9 minutes in heavily salted water to reach the perfect al dente stage. They should be flexible enough to stuff without tearing but firm enough to hold their shape during baking. After draining arrange them on a baking sheet to cool slightly rather than stacking which can cause them to stick together and tear. This small step makes the stuffing process much easier and ensures professional-looking results.

Pin it

Make It Budget Friendly

While this recipe shines with lobster and crab you can create a more affordable version that still delivers impressive flavor. Substitute half or all of the seafood with cooked shrimp which provides excellent texture and flavor at a lower price point. Another option is using imitation crab made from white fish which works surprisingly well in this creamy context. The key is maintaining that seafood essence while making the dish more accessible for regular family dinners rather than only special occasions.

Sauce Variations

The classic cream sauce in this recipe serves as a wonderful foundation that can be customized to your preference. For a touch of brightness add a tablespoon of fresh lemon zest to the sauce while cooking. If you enjoy a hint of heat incorporate a pinch of red pepper flakes to the garlic sautéing step. For an elevated flavor profile add ¼ cup of dry white wine after cooking the garlic and reduce it by half before continuing with the flour. Each variation maintains the luxurious texture while allowing you to tailor the dish to your personal taste or complement your wine selection.

Serving Suggestions

These stuffed shells make a stunning centerpiece when served family style directly from the baking dish. Garnish with finely chopped fresh parsley or chives just before bringing to the table for a professional touch of color. For individual plating place 3-4 shells on warmed plates with a drizzle of the sauce and a small wedge of lemon on the side. Complete the meal with a simple vegetable like roasted asparagus or steamed broccolini to balance the richness of the dish.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prepare these stuffed shells ahead of time?

Yes! You can assemble the stuffed shells up to 24 hours in advance. Keep them covered in the refrigerator and add an extra 5-10 minutes to the baking time when cooking from cold. For best results, prepare the sauce just before baking.

→ What can I substitute for lobster meat?

Shrimp makes an excellent substitute for lobster in this dish. Simply chop peeled, deveined shrimp into small pieces. You could also use scallops or even salmon for a different but equally delicious seafood version.

→ How do I prevent the pasta shells from tearing?

Cook the pasta shells just until al dente (slightly firm), usually 1-2 minutes less than package directions. Rinse them immediately with cold water after cooking to stop the cooking process, and handle them gently when stuffing. Having a few extra shells on hand is also wise in case some do tear.

→ What side dishes pair well with seafood stuffed shells?

Light sides work best to balance the richness: a simple green salad with lemon vinaigrette, roasted asparagus, sautéed spinach, or garlic bread to soak up the sauce. A crisp white wine like Pinot Grigio or Sauvignon Blanc complements the seafood flavors beautifully.

→ Can I freeze these stuffed shells?

Yes, you can freeze them before baking. Arrange stuffed shells in a freezer-safe container without the sauce, cover tightly, and freeze for up to 1 month. When ready to serve, prepare the fresh sauce, pour over frozen shells, and bake at 375°F for about 40-45 minutes until heated through.

→ How can I tell when the stuffed shells are done baking?

The dish is ready when the sauce is bubbling around the edges and the cheese on top has melted and turned a light golden brown. The internal temperature should reach 165°F if you're using a food thermometer to check for food safety.